When staying in Old San Juan, we always stay at El Convento. It's absolutely centrally-located and easy walking distance to everything. However, also far enough from the main plazas that it is quiet in the evenings. The staff are friendly and go out of their way to accommodate. A BIG thank you to Jesus, our favorite bartender! He was amazing and always with a smile. The front desk was incredibly helpful with local 'must-go' suggestions including best time to visit. And, a smiling thank you to our room steward who stopped by every evening with chocolates! El Convento is wonderful and and an unforgettable experience!