If you want a five star experience you'd be better to look at the sanitised, identical hotels on Antigua that can be found anywhere in the world. However if you prefer a family run hotel that will treat you as an individual and not just another customer then La Galleria is the place for you.
It was not busy when I visited so I just chose the room I wanted when I arrived, although this might not be possible in high season.
On the day after my arrival Mr Gregory took me for a walk around the area, accompanied by his delightful children. They gave me information and advice on where to go, and booked for me when I wished to go on trips. Anything I asked for was given to me. I had breakfast included in my deal which was lovely, but self catered the rest of the time. There was an adequate fridge in my room plus a gas cooker with some cooking and eating equipment.
Most important for me as a lone female was this place is safe. I was working as well as on holiday so I had my laptop with me, plus mobile phone and I felt totally able to leave these items in the unlocked cupboard in my room. I trusted the staff completely and knew they would not be taken or touched when my room was cleaned every day. The lock on my room was totally secure.
I'd say this hotel might suit independent travellers and backpackers like myself best. The prices are reasonable on what can be a very expensive travel desination, so keep your expectations in line with this and you won't be disappointed.