We stayed at the Fairholm 3 nights. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. The property was well maintained and had a historic charm. We drove to PEI, and I have some dietary restrictions, so it would have been nice to have had a mini fridge in the room to put some of the food items we had with us. They did have ice so we were able to keep items chilled in the cooler we brought. The rooms are a good size so it should be something for them to consider adding to the amenities.
Parking is limited. We were on the 3rd floor so trekking our luggage and ourselves up 3 floors was a little daunting. The facility is also not wheel chair accessible so I wouldn't stay here if you need that accommodation. The room was very clean but the bed was not the most comfortable. Furthermore, the light from the hallway was blaring through the crack in the door and with the bed right there it was hard to sleep. The second night and third night, I turned the two lights off and it was better with just the stairway light on. Our air conditioner was dripping on the floor when we got there, so we had to use a bucket so it wouldn't wreck the hardwood floors, but they replaced it with a window air conditioner and that was good. Overall, the hotel has the historic quaint feel of Charlottetown. It was walking distance to many restaurants in the downtown. If you don't require a mini fridge and don't mind trekking up and down 3 flights of stairs then it's a nice place to stay.