Mahogany Bay Resort & Beach Club, Curio Collection by Hilton

Beautiful property with great staff. The beach was wonderful even if you could only access by boat. Further from town than we were expecting but renting a golf cart was easy and enjoyable! Would definitely go back!

Overall a good place to stay but a few things to note, from my personal point of view" 1. If you like having all services available on-site and do not care about pricing, this is a great spot for you. Anything you want to book through the resort will cost extra. 2. There is a resort fee, but really the only free extra item beyond other higher-end places to stay is the fitness room and private beach (which is awesome. There are few other places on the island that have as nice of a beach and water access). In 2019 they provided a free continental breakfast, no longer in 2020. 3. The one-room huts are not really quiet, especially closer to the entrance. I suggest the property does not allow golf carts to drive past a certain point. The cart noise is constant in the mornings and loud. 4. They advertise other food huts open during the day. However, there is no guarantee they will actually be open. You may go an only the ice cream stand is open. 5. The staff is great and willing to help. I'd expect that at any tourist place I stay, however. 6. I recommend going off-site for food. Cheaper options in town and more authentic. Nothing wrong with the food on the resort, you will just pay a premium. My personal conclusion, the private beach is the reason to stay here. However, with some of the changes in breakfast and not having a hut further back from the entrance I would evaluate other options before booking again.

This is a nice resort off the busy and loud downtown areas. Little huts are very cozy and super clean. Avoid getting one right next to the little resort roads as the noise of the passing golf carts can be annoying at times. Private beach is gorgeous - just remember that you have to go with their time schedule. There is no other beach area at the resort - so to get into the ocean you need to take the water taxi.

The beach is gorgeous and kinda personal because only a few people are throughout. We had only 2 other people on the boat with us to get there. The staff are very nice and helpful. The landscape is beautiful and the price for food are fair. However the not having windows in the room may keep me from returning idk..very loud! but soooo beautiful to listen to the birds and the rain. Just not the banging, golf carts and talking. More pros than con :)

It was great!! Nothing else to say

Overall the place is good. It's brand new and the rooms are very clean. The service could be a lot better. We rented a day bed at the beach club ($75) and there was no bartender. We also locked ourselves out and it took 30 min for someone to bring us a key. The place is far from any bars so you are forced to eat and drink there. The sushi place is amazing. The local bar charged me $25 for a cadillac margarita which I though was egregious. Rooms are very very clean but they have the AC positioned right on you so you are too hot if you turn it off and have a strong draft if it's on you. Lastly, we paid $150 for the room through hotels.com but then had to pay a $50 resort fee on top of it.

I loved the ambiance. The breakfast was amazing and service was excellent. My only complaint would be that the washclothes were not replaced everyday. The staff were very friendly and helpful.

It was incredibly beautiful, awesome and the best place to stay. I would totally stay there again and will if or when I return to San Pedro. You MUST stay here.The staff is awesome, amazing, super helpful, hospitable and great in every way. Food is also delicious. Private island is stunning. Everything about it is perfect.

This was clearly the BEST place to stay in San Pedro! The Resort made for the perfect family vacation... Staff was awesome and the food was divine! Bet sashumi I have had in a very long time.

The best trip ever! The staff was absolutely amazing. Would not change a thing.